Experience

Edward specialises in personal injury and employment, and has substantial experience of related fields including clinical negligence, inquests and criminal injuries compensation claims. He is particularly experienced in motor and other insurance fraud cases, and has specialist knowledge of all aspects of this area of litigation, including exaggerated claims, deliberately-induced collisions, and fraud rings, as well as linked issues including committal and costs.

Education

LL.B (Hons) Nottingham
Inns of Court School of Law

Professional Memberships

Personal Injuries Bar Association
Middle Temple

Languages

French

Public Access

Undertakes Public Access work

Nawaz v Belmehdi

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Andrew Auchterlounie of Keoghs, represented the successful Defendant and his insurers in this significant fraud case.

The Claimant claimed damages including a credit hire claim of over £86,000, following a road traffic collision alleged to have occurred when the Defendant reversed into the Claimant’s motorcycle. The claim was defended on the basis that it was fraudulent, the impact being the Claimant’s fault for driving into the Defendant’s stationary vehicle, and that the Claimant’s evidence about the accident and his losses could not be believed.

After a trial in Wandsworth County Court, involving oral evidence from the parties, and expert forensic engineering evidence, the claims were dismissed. The Judge held that the claim was fraudulent, the Claimant’s evidence having included a high degree of inconsistency and embellishment. She also found that the Claimant misled the court about his financial position, which underpinned his hire claim, and that his evidence about his other losses was unbelievable, so that the entire claim was fundamentally dishonest.

The claims were therefore dismissed, and an enforceable costs order made in favour of the Defendant. The Judge also provided for the Defendant to make an application for non-party costs against the hire company.


Askarnia & Khorzanian v Field & Groarke

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Hannah Lowe of Keoghs, represented the successful First Defendant and her insurers in this major fraud case. Two related Claimants claimed damages for following a road traffic collision involving a multi-car shunt.

Read more

Shajahan & Others v Addr & Churchill

Edward Hutchin, instructed  by Eli Wieder of Keoghs, represented the successful Defendant insurer in this case in which 2 Claimants were claiming damages following an alleged road traffic accident in Birmingham. The Defendant driver did not cooperate with his insurers, but the claim was defended on the basis that the Claimants’ evidence about the accident could not be believed, and that they were part of a fraudulent scheme to make false compensation claims. After a 4 day trial the judge dismissed the claims, finding that they were fraudulent. The Claimants were ordered to pay the Defendant insurer’s costs of defending their claims on an indemnity basis.


Peart v Carphone Warehouse UKEAT/0457/13/BA

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Carphone Warehouse, represented the successful Respondent in this case in which the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld an appeal against the decision of the ET.

Read more

Martin v Carphone Warehouse UKEAT/0371/12/JOJ

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Carphone Warehouse, represented the successful Respondent in this case in which the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld an appeal against the decision of the ET. The EAT considered the concept of disability discrimination and its relation to failures to pay wages, as well as ancillary claims of constructive dismissal and breach of contract.


Armsden v Kent Police [2009] EWCA Civ 631

Edward, instructed by Ian Walker of BLM, represented the successful Police Force in this case in which the Court of Appeal upheld an appeal against the decision of the trial judge. The case involved consideration of the factors affecting liability of police emergency drivers involved in a fatal accident claim.


TGC Fraud Update February 2016

3rd February 2016

Facing up to the challenge of fraud rings.
Please see link below for the second edition of TGC Fraud Update, a publication which was set up with the stated aim of facilitating the sharing of information about decided claims involving issues of road traffic fraud and related matters. Thank you also for all of the kind words and helpful feedback received about the inaugural edition.

 


View External Link

Javed & Bhatti v Aviva

6th April 2018

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Kirsty Taylor of Keoghs solicitors, represented the successful Defendant insurers in this fraud case. The Claimants claimed damages for personal injuries and losses allegedly sustained when the Defendant’s insured collided with the rear of the vehicle in which they were travelling as it left a roundabout.

Read more

False claims dismissed

19th October 2017

Dishonest claim by mother and children rejected. Edward Hutchin, instructed by Ryan Sweetnam of Keoghs solicitors, represented the successful Defendant and his insurers in this fraud case.

Read more

Fraud claims dismissed

27th September 2017

Dishonest claim for £86,000 rejected. Edward Hutchin, instructed by Andrew Auchterlounie of Keoghs, represented the successful Defendant and his insurers in this significant fraud case.

Read more

Fraud claim dismissed

13th October 2016

Fundamentally dishonest Claimants lose compensation claim. Edward Hutchin, instructed by Hannah Lowe of Keoghs, represented the successful First Defendant and her insurers in this major fraud case.

Read more

Stanmore Quality Surfacing Ltd v Kartel

21st July 2016

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Andrew Thomson of DAC Beachcrofts on behalf of Allianz insurance, successfully represented the insured company in this case, in which orders for committal for contempt of court were made against 4 dishonest claimants, who were sentenced to 6 months imprisonment each.

Read more

Privacy Notice

Thank you for choosing to instruct me in your case. I will need to collect and hold your personal information in order to represent you. I will take all reasonably practicable steps to protect your personal information. I am determined to do nothing that would infringe your rights or undermine your trust. This Privacy Notice describes the information I  collect about you, how it is used and shared, and your rights regarding it.

Data Controller

I am registered with the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) as a Data Controller for the personal data that I hold and process as a barrister. My registered address is Temple Garden Chambers, 1 Harcourt Buildings, Temple, London EC4Y 9DA and my registration number is Z4708056.

Data Collection

The vast majority of the information that I hold about you is provided to or gathered by me in the course of your case and/or proceedings. Your solicitor and/or I will tell you why we need the information and how we will use it.

Our Lawful Basis for processing your information

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires all organisations that process personal data to have a Lawful Basis for doing so. The Lawful Bases identified in the GDPR are:

  • Consent of the data subject
  • Performance of a contract with the data subject or to take steps to enter into a contract
  • Compliance with a legal obligation
  • To protect the vital interests of a data subject or another person
  • Performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller.
  • The legitimate interests of myself, or a third party, except where such interests are overridden by the interests, rights or freedoms of the data subject.

Examples of legitimate interests include:

  • Where the data subject is a client or in the service of the controller;
  • Transmission within a group of undertakings for internal administrative purposes;
  • Processing necessary to ensure network and information security, including preventing unauthorised access;
  • Processing for direct marketing purposes, or to prevent fraud; and
  • Reporting possible criminal acts or threats to public security.

Our Lawful Basis is Consent of the data subject and/or Performance of a contract with the data subject and/or the Legitimate Interests of myself, and my Legitimate Interest is that the data subject is my client.

I use your information to:

  • Provide legal advice and representation
  • Assist in training pupils and mini-pupils
  • Investigate and address your concerns
  • Communicate with you about news, updates and events
  • Investigate or address legal proceedings relating to your use of my services, or as otherwise allowed by applicable law

I do not use automated decision-making in the processing of your personal data.

I collect and process both personal data and special categories of personal data as defined in the GDPR. This includes:

Client data

  • Name;
  • Email;
  • Phone number;
  • Address;
  • National Insurance and benefits details;
  • Payment or bank details;
  • Date of birth;
  • Location details;
  • Device IP address;
  • Financial and insurance information;
  • Medical Records and information;
  • Criminal Records;
  • Education and social background;
  • Religious and ethnic background;
  • Social and other media.

I may share your personal data with:

  • Instructing solicitors
  • Pupil or mini pupil, under my training or that of another suitable member of chambers
  • Opposing or other Counsel, for the purposes of resolving the case
  • The Court staff and judge for the purposes of resolving the case
  • My Chambers management and staff who provide administrative services
  • My regulator or legal or financial advisors in the event of a dispute or other legal or administrative matter
  • Law enforcement officials, government authorities, or other third parties to meet my legal obligations
  • Any other party where I ask you and you consent to the sharing

Transfers to third countries and international organisations

I do not usually transfer any personal data to third countries or international organisations.

I may transfer personal data to the following third countries or international organisations using the identified safeguards because I may use third party email storage facilities in the course of the case.

  • UK or EC storage
  • USA – where complying with the Privacy Shield requirements or approved by EC

I am satisfied that such transferred data is fully protected and safeguarded as required by the General Data Protection Regulation.

I retain your personal data while you remain a client unless you ask me to delete it. My Retention and Disposal Policy (copy available on request) details how long I hold data for and how I dispose of it when it no longer needs to be held. I will delete or anonymise your information at your request unless:

  • There is an unresolved issue, such as claim or dispute;
  • I am legally required to; or
  • There are overriding legitimate business interests, including but not limited to fraud prevention and protecting customers’ safety and security, and retaining data in order to deal with any further issues arising in relation to your case.

Your Rights

The General Data Protection Regulation gives you specific rights around your personal data. For example, you have to be informed about the information I hold and what I use it for, you can ask for a copy of the personal information I hold about you, you can ask us to correct any inaccuracies with the personal data I hold, you can ask us to stop sending you direct mail, or emails, or in some circumstances ask us to stop processing your details. Finally, if I do something irregular or improper with your personal data you can seek compensation for any distress you are caused or loss you have incurred. You can find out more information from the ICO’s website http://ico.org.uk/for_the_public/personal_information and this is the organisation that you can complain to if you are unhappy with how I dealt with you.

Accessing and Correcting Your Information

You may request access to, correction of, or a copy of your information by contacting me at Temple Garden Chambers, 1 Harcourt Buildings, Temple, London EC4Y 9DA.

Marketing Opt-Outs

You may opt out of receiving emails and other messages from my Chambers by following the instructions in those messages.

Cookies

Cookies are small text files that are stored on your browser or device by websites, apps, online media, and advertisements. The Chambers website use cookies to:

  • Validate users
  • Remember user preferences and settings
  • Determine frequency of accessing our content
  • Measure the effectiveness of advertising campaigns; and
  • Analyse site visits and trend

I will occasionally update my Privacy Notice. When I make significant changes, I will notify you of these through either mail or email.