Home / Resources / TGC Fraud Update – Issue XIII March 2022

TGC Fraud Update – Issue XIII March 2022

18/03/2022

Welcome to the latest edition of the TGC Fraud Update.

These are busy times. As foreshadowed in previous editions of this update, the introduction of the whiplash reforms has seen a substantial rise in the ‘layering’ of previously straightforward claims with claims for treatments in various guises, and claims associated with recognised psychiatric injuries. Those increases come at the same time as a significant rise in credit hire claims arising from incidents involving motorcycle couriers and delivery drivers, no doubt fuelled in part by the enormous demand for ‘dine-in’ services, as well as the shifting business models of the credit hire and accident management industries. Many of the resulting claims from 2020 and 2021 still remain a long way from trial, and judging by the number of aged claims that are listed for trial, but are being vacated at the last minute due to a lack of judicial availability, the number of claims filling lists in the County Court is likely to persist for years to come.

Meanwhile, the High Court continues to deal with increasing volumes of serious and high-value injury claims in which allegations of fundamental dishonesty are being alleged.

In this issue:

  • James Yapp looks at the Supreme Court decision in Ho v Adelekun [2021] UKSC 43, with notes of caution in relation to offers of settlement and enforcement of costs in QOCS cases.
  • Tim Sharpe analyses two recent High Court decisions on the application of s.57, and considers the tricky issue of claimants hiding behind mistakes or decisions of their representatives.
  • Robert Riddell considers the decision of the Court of Appeal in Griffiths v TUI [201] EWCA Civ 1442 concerning the judicial evaluation of ‘uncontroverted’ expert evidence.
  • Anisa Kassamali examines the distinction between dishonest exaggeration and fundamental dishonesty in the context of Elgamal v Westminster City Council [2021] EWHC 5210 (QB).
  • I take a look at the principles guiding the amendment of pleadings to advance a positive case of dishonesty, and whether there is a need to do so in light of Howlett and the recent decisions in Covey v Harris [2021] EWHC 2211 (QB), Mustard v Flower [2021] EWHC 846 (QB) and Cojanu v Essex Partnership University NHS Trust [2022] EWHC 197 (QB).

As always, these articles are accompanied by summaries and interesting practice points taken from a host of recent decisions in the types of cases that we all deal with on a daily basis.
Please do contact a member of the TGC fraud team if you have any queries about any of the items dealt with in this issue, or indeed about any other issues relating to insurance fraud and related matters.

I hope that the contents of this newsletter are both interesting and useful; as ever I would welcome any feedback from our readers.

Download File

Related Barristers

Clinical Negligence
Credit Hire
Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury
Automated & Electric Vehicles

Edward Hutchin

Call 1996

Read more

Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury
Inquests
Health & Safety
Credit Hire

Tim Sharpe

Call 2002

Read more

Personal Injury
Motor Insurance Fraud
Clinical Negligence
Costs & Litigation Funding
ADR & Mediation
Automated & Electric Vehicles

Anthony Johnson

Call 2006

Read more

Insurance
Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury

James Henry

Call 2010

Read more

Costs & Litigation Funding
Credit Hire
Insurance
Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury

James Yapp

Call 2014

Read more

Costs & Litigation Funding
Insurance
Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury
Public Law

Robert Riddell

Call 2015

Read more

Automated & Electric Vehicles
Extradition & Interpol
Health & Safety
Inquests
Inquiries
Insurance
Motor Insurance Fraud
Personal Injury
Public Law
Professional Discipline

Anisa Kassamali

Call 2020

Read more

Search


Menu

Close

Portfolio Builder

Select the practice areas that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Portfolio
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)