Home / Resources / James Arney KC secures £6.4m contributory negligence reduction in tetraplegic claim

James Arney KC secures £6.4m contributory negligence reduction in tetraplegic claim


James Arney KC, instructed for the Defendant by Horwich Farrelly, settled a tetraplegic RTA claim with a substantial reduction for both failing to wear a seatbelt and the Claimant allowing himself to be driven by someone impaired through alcohol consumption. Key quantum issues included life expectancy, double-up care, CCG funding and the cost of alternative accommodation.

James Arney KC represented the Defendant in JSM negotiations arising from an RTA in which the then 17-year old claimant was an unseat-belted rear passenger of a car which rolled 270 degrees being driven by a newly qualified driver who was impaired by alcohol. The Defendant contended throughout that the combined effect of seatbelt and alcohol merited a 30% reduction for contributory negligence. Despite the claimant challenging both causation in respect of the seatbelt failing and negligence in respect of the driver’s intoxication, post-settlement comments from those representing the claimant are consistent with the 30% reduction ultimately being accepted. With settlement at a net figure of £15m, the contributory negligence deduction amounted to over £6.4m.

Other key issues in the case included:

  • Life expectancy, with the Defendant adducing expert evidence from a life expectancy expert explaining why the Claimant’s spinal injury would lower his life expectancy below that advised by the spinal experts.
  • Care, with the Defendant’s care expert challenging the Claimant’s contention that 24/7 double up care would be required.
  • Considering the extent to which credit should be given in respect of the £212k per annum CCG funding currently received by the Claimant.
  • Accommodation, with significant challenge being raised to the Claimant’s proposed alternative housing adaptations.

The JSM was a fitting last working commitment of the Defendant’s solicitor, Rod Evans. We wish him a long and happy retirement.

Related Barristers

Personal Injury
Clinical Negligence
Costs & Litigation Funding

James Arney KC

Call 1992 | Silk 2021

Read more

Related Practice Areas

Personal Injury




Portfolio Builder

Select the practice areas that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)