Accommodation Claims: Swift v Carpenter: Court of Appeal decision


Practice Areas

Personal Injury

James Arney appeared as sole counsel in the quantum trial in 2018, and was led on this appeal by Derek Sweeting QC, instructed by Grant Incles of Leigh Day & Co.

This case involved re-consideration of the mechanism for assessing the loss to a claimant of having to fund the purchase of special alternative accommodation. The previous mechanism, derived from the decision in Roberts v Johnstone [1989] QB 878, was challenged as being “unfit for purpose”, both by reason of the current negative discount rate which produced a nil valuation in all cases, and more generally.

In this long-awaited landmark decision, the Court of Appeal has held that Roberts v Johnstone does not give full and fair compensation and should be replaced. Instead a new mechanism has been created, based upon calculating the “market value” of the notional reversionary interest (using a +5% investment rate), which is to be deducted from the full capital value of the increased cost of the special accommodation.

This decision impacts on the vast majority of high value personal injury claims, significantly increasing the awards that claimants will achieve.

Related Barristers

James Arney QC

James Arney QC
Year of Call: 1992
Year of Silk: 2021

Close X

TEMPLE GARDEN CHAMBERS is a market leading set with recognised excellence in a myriad of practice areas with awarded leaders in twelve specialist areas. TGC has the privilege of being well placed in the Temple and The Hague with superb facilities.

Currently consisting of 17 silks and 60 juniors with outstanding leadership and a long established clerking team acknowledged for their exceptional client services and business development, we are keen to expand upon our key areas.

To accommodate the growth in our core practice areas we are inviting applications from established practitioners and/or teams to further enhance our excellent reputation in the following fields:

• Personal Injury & Clinical Negligence
• Inquests & Inquiries
• Health & Safety
• Costs & Litigation Funding

TGC is widely recognised for its friendly ethos and its commitment to Equality & Diversity and Wellbeing. We are especially keen to encourage applications from underrepresented groups at the bar – women, people with disabilities, those from ethnic minority groups and members of the LGBTQ+ community.

Applications will be treated with the strictest confidence and should be addressed to the Head of Chambers, Keith Morton QC

In advance of any formal application both Keith Morton QC and Dean Norton (Senior Clerk) would be delighted to have a confidential discussion. To arrange a meeting please contact Dean on 020 7842 8641 or