News & Resources

Fundamentally dishonest Claimant imprisoned for contempt of court

10th August 2017

Tim Sharpe (instructed by Miles Cowan of Horwich Farrelly) represented Hastings Insurance on a committal application before HHJ Moloney QC, sitting as a Judge of the High Court in the Norwich District Registry, on 9th August 2017. The application for committal of the Claimant (Mr John Egner) was based on false statements made in document bearing statements of truth, namely his Claim Form, Particulars of Claim and Part 18 Replies.

In summary, Mr Egner’s van was damaged by a driver insured by Hastings, as a result of which that individual was prosecuted for causing criminal damage. Some two years after this incident, Mr Egner presented a claim to Hastings for back injuries allegedly sustained by him in that incident. His claim was subsequently issued, and in his Claim Form and Particulars of Claim he claimed to have been the driver of the van at the time it was struck and that as a result he sustained injuries (as also set out in detail in a medical report). He further set out his case on how he was injured by way of Part 18 Replies, claiming that he was jolted in his seat and that the pain was so much that he had to take time off work as he could not lift or even walk. Hastings contended that the claim was dishonest and in support of the contention that Mr Egner was not in fact in the van at the material time, relied on statements that Mr Egner himself and his then partner had provided to the police in connection with the prosecution of the insured driver, in which they confirmed they had witnessed the criminal damage take place from the pavement. The county court claim was transferred to the High Court and ultimately struck out. Upon the court granting the insurer’s application for permission to bring proceedings for contempt, Mr Egner admitted his contempt.

At the hearing on 9th August 2017, the court committed Mr Egner to an immediate period of custody of 8 weeks, reduced from 12 weeks to reflect his admission. He was also ordered to pay £5,000 towards the costs of the original action and a further £9,000 towards the costs of the committal proceedings.

In the course of judgement, HHJ Moloney QC noted that dishonest but low value “whiplash” claims cost the insurance industry immense legal costs and that the public pays more in premiums. The court noted that the background to the claim (a cold call) was typical of the problem, and precisely the type of case to which the policy explained by Moses LJ in South Wales Fire & Rescue v Smith  [2011] EWHC 1749 (Admin) applies, namely that those who make such false claims should expect to go to prison and that there is no other way to underline the gravity of such conduct, or to deter those tempted to make such claims. The court considered that on the facts of the case, to suspend the sentence would detract from the policy of deterrence.





Related Barristers

Tim Sharpe

Tim Sharpe
Year of Call: 2002


Close X

Coronavirus Update

TGC continues proactively to safeguard against the risks posed by the spread of Coronavirus. We have a Covid-19 Committee who continue to monitor the situation and follow advice issued by the Government and Public Health England. We will be updating this page as and when new information becomes available. As of 6 July 2020, our London premises, 1 Harcourt Buildings, will be operating with a reduced clerking team in attendance. The remaining staff members and barristers will continue working remotely. We wish to reassure everyone that our contingency plans enable us to continue to provide our services.

Telephoning us

When calling our switchboard number, it will be diverted to a member of the clerking team who will be able to assist in the usual way. All direct dials in Chambers are diverted to be answered remotely.

Emailing us & Sending Instructions

Please send all instructions via email directly to clerks@tgchambers.com. We would be grateful if this could be sent in an orderly fashion to enable working from a screen manageable. We are able to receive hard copy instructions via DX or Post, if necessary. However, we have a preference for electronic documents wherever possible.

Please continue to communicate with barristers directly via phone or email.

Conferences, Joint Settlement Meetings & Mediations

Conferences, meetings and mediations will take place remotely, either by telephone or video until further notice. Group Telephone calls and video calls can be easily arranged. If an in-person meeting is felt necessary please see our Covid-19 Information page for full criteria.

Court Hearings

We are following the Government’s advice closely, which is changing daily. In keeping with that advice, we will continue to service hearings remotely, where possible and as instructed by the hosting Court. In-Person hearings will be accommodated by members of TGC. We will continue to monitor this situation.

Making a payment

If you do not already pay us by BACS, going forward please make arrangements to do so. Please contact the clerks who can supply you with the relevant BACS details.

If you wish to discuss our policy and procedure relating to coronavirus, please do not hesitate to contact our senior clerk Dean Norton on 07535 753098 or dnorton@tgchambers.com.

To learn more visit our Covid-19 Information page.