News & Resources

Hibberd-Little v Carlton [2018] EWHC 1787 (QB)

6th July 2018

Judge dismisses subtle brain injury claim for £4,434,307. Jonathan Watt-Pringle QC, instructed by Clyde & Co, for the Defendant.

The claimant, a highly intelligent teacher, was injured in a rear-end shunt, in which the impact speed was appreciably less than 30 mph. Having started a claim in the Portal, she later proceeded in the High Court, alleging that she had suffered Diffuse Axonal Injury and audio-vestibular injuries, and that she had been left with a collection of life-changing neurogenic and cognitive symptoms. As a result, she had had to give up a stellar teaching career and had opened a tea room with disastrous financial consequences.

The Judge found her evidence inconsistent, inaccurate and unreliable, and he rejected the evidence on brain injury of her expert witnesses in the fields of neurology and psychology: see [90] – [103] & [104] – [131]. The Judge was particularly critical of the psychologist’s evidence. He found a lack of transparency about her professional disciplinary record, and was not satisfied that she was sufficiently independent and objective as an expert witness to be of any real assistance to the court; moreover, her dual function as an expert witness and treating therapist was a “serious problem”: see [110] – [120].

Following the 11-day trial, the claimant was awarded £41,250 (inclusive of interest), which amounted to 0.93% of her claim for £4,434,307. She was awarded 25% of her costs until the date of the defendant’s Part 36 offer, and ordered to pay the defendant’s costs thereafter, plus backdated interest thereon. Although this was a QOCS case, the Judge directed that the claimant’s costs should be set-off against the defendant’s costs.

The judgment can be viewed here.

Close X

TEMPLE GARDEN CHAMBERS is a market leading set with recognised excellence in a myriad of practice areas with awarded leaders in twelve specialist areas. TGC has the privilege of being well placed in the Temple and The Hague with superb facilities.

Currently consisting of 17 silks and 60 juniors with outstanding leadership and a long established clerking team acknowledged for their exceptional client services and business development, we are keen to expand upon our key areas.

To accommodate the growth in our core practice areas we are inviting applications from established practitioners and/or teams to further enhance our excellent reputation in the following fields:

• Personal Injury & Clinical Negligence
• Inquests & Inquiries
• Health & Safety
• Costs & Litigation Funding

TGC is widely recognised for its friendly ethos and its commitment to Equality & Diversity and Wellbeing. We are especially keen to encourage applications from underrepresented groups at the bar – women, people with disabilities, those from ethnic minority groups and members of the LGBTQ+ community.

Applications will be treated with the strictest confidence and should be addressed to the Head of Chambers, Keith Morton QC

In advance of any formal application both Keith Morton QC and Dean Norton (Senior Clerk) would be delighted to have a confidential discussion. To arrange a meeting please contact Dean on 020 7842 8641 or