News & Resources

Stanmore Quality Surfacing Ltd v Kartel

21st July 2016

Edward Hutchin, instructed by Andrew Thomson of DAC Beachcrofts on behalf of Allianz insurance, successfully represented the insured company in this case, in which orders for committal for contempt of court were made against 4 dishonest claimants, who were sentenced to 6 months imprisonment each.

All 4 claimants made claims for compensation following a road traffic collision. A defence was filed alleging that the collision was deliberately induced. Following a trial in Nottingham County Court in 2015, HHJ Godsmark QC dismissed the claims, finding that the claims formed part of a fraud ring involved in arranging false road traffic collision claims. The claims were dismissed, with indemnity costs in favour of the Defendant.

The insured, in conjunction with its insurers, was not content to let the matter rest there. An application was therefore made against all 4 claimants for their committal for contempt of court. In particular it was alleged that they had all dishonestly stated that 1 of the claimants was present at the time of the collision, and that the witness evidence of the insured that he was a bogus passenger was supported by photographs taken at the scene which showed another unidentified individual in the car. The claimants opposed the application, and challenged the authenticity of the photographic evidence.

After a 2 day hearing in Nottingham District Registry, at which all 4 of the original claimants gave evidence, and the court considered expert computing evidence obtained by both parties, HHJ Godsmark QC, sitting as a High Court Judge, found all 4 litigants guilty of contempt of court. Although they advanced mitigation including ill health and the advanced pregnancy of 1 of the participants, the Judge held that only an immediate custodial sentence was appropriate, and sentenced each of them to 6 months imprisonment.

Related Barristers

Edward Hutchin

Edward Hutchin
Year of Call: 1996

Close X

TEMPLE GARDEN CHAMBERS is a market leading set with recognised excellence in a myriad of practice areas with awarded leaders in twelve specialist areas. TGC has the privilege of being well placed in the Temple and The Hague with superb facilities.

Currently consisting of 17 silks and 60 juniors with outstanding leadership and a long established clerking team acknowledged for their exceptional client services and business development, we are keen to expand upon our key areas.

To accommodate the growth in our core practice areas we are inviting applications from established practitioners and/or teams to further enhance our excellent reputation in the following fields:

• Personal Injury & Clinical Negligence
• Inquests & Inquiries
• Health & Safety
• Costs & Litigation Funding

TGC is widely recognised for its friendly ethos and its commitment to Equality & Diversity and Wellbeing. We are especially keen to encourage applications from underrepresented groups at the bar – women, people with disabilities, those from ethnic minority groups and members of the LGBTQ+ community.

Applications will be treated with the strictest confidence and should be addressed to the Head of Chambers, Keith Morton QC

In advance of any formal application both Keith Morton QC and Dean Norton (Senior Clerk) would be delighted to have a confidential discussion. To arrange a meeting please contact Dean on 020 7842 8641 or