News & Resources

Swift v Carpenter: permission to appeal refused, and Respondent to pay costs.

6th November 2020

Following the substantive appeal judgment in this test case on accommodation claims which was handed down on 9th October 2020, in which James Arney continues to act for Mrs. Swift The Court of Appeal today handed down their ruling on the costs of the appeal and the Respondent’s application for permission to appeal.

Permission to appeal was refused.

The Respondent has been ordered to pay Mrs. Swift’s costs of the appeal, rejecting arguments made by the Respondent that the 2019 adjournment to enable expert evidence to be adduced merited a different approach.

The Court distinguished the case of Cheeseman v Bowaters [1971] 1 WLR 1773 (where a late amendment to pleadings to add a new claim had resulted in a claimant not recovering all costs despite beating the defendant’s offer).

The Court in Swift had regard to the fact that Mrs. Swift had beaten her own without prejudice offer to accept £800,000 made in August 2018, and had comfortably beaten the Respondent’s without prejudice and Part 36 offer of £600,000.

In addition, Part 36 consequences applied to costs from 23/7/19 (pursuant to Mrs. Swift beating her own Part 36 offer to accept £800,000), with the Respondent ordered to pay: –

a) Costs from that time on the indemnity basis;
b) Additional damages of over £65,000
c) Interest on damages at 4.5%, amounting to over £43,000;
d) Interest on costs at 4.5%.

When account is taken of the additional damages, interest on damages and the appeal award of £801,913, Mrs. Swift’s total damages figures exceeds the £900,000 full capital value that was in issue between the parties on the appeal.

It is understood that the Respondent is considering renewing that application before the Supreme Court.

James Arney, led by Derek Sweeting QC on the appeal, instructed by Grant Incles of Leigh Day.

The Judgment can be found below.

Download PDF

Related Barristers

James Arney QC

James Arney QC
Year of Call: 1992
Year of Silk: 2021

Close X

Coronavirus Update

TGC continues proactively to safeguard against the risks posed by the spread of Coronavirus. We have a Covid-19 Committee who continue to monitor the situation and follow advice issued by the Government and Public Health England. We will be updating this page as and when new information becomes available. As of 6 July 2020, our London premises, 1 Harcourt Buildings, will be operating with a reduced clerking team in attendance. The remaining staff members and barristers will continue working remotely. We wish to reassure everyone that our contingency plans enable us to continue to provide our services.

Telephoning us

When calling our switchboard number, it will be diverted to a member of the clerking team who will be able to assist in the usual way. All direct dials in Chambers are diverted to be answered remotely.

Emailing us & Sending Instructions

Please send all instructions via email directly to We would be grateful if this could be sent in an orderly fashion to enable working from a screen manageable. We are able to receive hard copy instructions via DX or Post, if necessary. However, we have a preference for electronic documents wherever possible.

Please continue to communicate with barristers directly via phone or email.

Conferences, Joint Settlement Meetings & Mediations

Conferences, meetings and mediations will take place remotely, either by telephone or video until further notice. Group Telephone calls and video calls can be easily arranged. If an in-person meeting is felt necessary please see our Covid-19 Information page for full criteria.

Court Hearings

We are following the Government’s advice closely, which is changing daily. In keeping with that advice, we will continue to service hearings remotely, where possible and as instructed by the hosting Court. In-Person hearings will be accommodated by members of TGC. We will continue to monitor this situation.

Making a payment

If you do not already pay us by BACS, going forward please make arrangements to do so. Please contact the clerks who can supply you with the relevant BACS details.

If you wish to discuss our policy and procedure relating to coronavirus, please do not hesitate to contact our senior clerk Dean Norton on 07535 753098 or

To learn more visit our Covid-19 Information page.